Skip to content

Honest Healthcare Sharing Reviews: Insider Scoop

Get the Inside Scoop: Honest Healthcare Sharing Reviews


Are you tired of the ever-increasing premiums of traditional health insurance? Are you looking for an affordable and transparent healthcare option? Healthcare sharing plans offer just that! In this blog, we will help you understand what healthcare sharing plans are, how they compare to traditional health insurance, and the pros and cons of opting for such plans. We will also provide in-depth reviews of popular healthcare sharing plans like Samaritan Ministries and Medi-Share, and Impact Health Sharing. Additionally, we will cover how healthcare sharing programs handle catastrophic situations and chronic conditions. Lastly, we will discuss who can benefit from healthcare sharing options and if it could be a viable alternative for you. Read on to get the inside scoop on honest healthcare sharing reviews!


Understanding Healthcare Sharing Programs

Healthcare sharing plans offer a unique approach to healthcare, where members share each other’s medical costs according to the program's guidelines. Compared to traditional health insurance, these programs often cost less and are rooted in ethical principles of sharing and caring for others. Members of healthcare sharing groups typically share similar beliefs and values, making it a perfect fit for those seeking a more detailed look into group-based healthcare options. With some offering support in their communities along with low-cost alternatives for healthy people, it's a good thing that these plans exist, especially for those who can benefit from a healthcare sharing plan.


Defining Healthcare Sharing

Health care sharing plans involve the sharing of resources to pay medical expenses. Members make monthly payments to share medical costs when necessary, often following specific eligibility and member guidelines. These plans usually require members to adhere to a statement of faith or beliefs, with some requiring church attendance for Christian healthcare ministries. It's important to note that health care sharing programs may limit sharing of some medical expenses, such as pre-existing conditions. Additionally, these options usually don't operate within a PPO network, but for many, the lower cost compared to traditional health insurance is a big deal. In the United States, medical cost sharing is gaining popularity due to its low cost and transparency, making it a smart alternative for healthy individuals and families.

couple looking into healthcare on computer


Comparing Healthcare Sharing Programs to Traditional Health Insurance

Healthcare sharing plans provide an alternative to traditional health insurance, with some offering members more freedom in choosing healthcare providers. Unlike traditional insurance, these plans are not regulated by the Affordable Care Act and often involve a more direct approach to sharing medical expenses. While traditional insurance requires monthly premiums to an insurance company, healthcare sharing plans offer a different payment structure. Members of these plans typically have more input into their medical care and may find a more straightforward approach to sharing medical costs.


What are Some of the Pros and Cons of Healthcare Sharing?

This Impact Health Sharing member shared their honest review. "Wow! Impact has gone above and beyond! I knew I was saving when my monthly cost was cut by almost 1/3 after making the switch. That in itself was huge! But it gets better! I just got a notification that my husband Andy's prescription was ready for pickup. The cost reduction was 1/3 of what I paid before. And that was using Good Rx. Impact Health Sharing's prescription discounts gave us a much better price, which is less than $13.00 for a 90-day supply." - Bonnie G.

Some members of sharing programs are uncomfortable with explaining healthcare sharing to their providers, but options such as Impact Health Sharing have providers bill them directly and offer a letter of explanation to take the burden off the members.

Advantages of Healthcare Sharing

Healthcare sharing plans offer lower monthly contributions compared to traditional insurance, providing a more cost-effective option for individuals and families, seniors, and some small businesses. Members also benefit from a sense of community and shared values, fostering a supportive environment. Additionally, these programs may offer more personalized and direct healthcare cost-sharing options, allowing greater flexibility in managing medical expenses. Moreover, healthcare sharing plans provide an alternative for those seeking a faith-based approach to healthcare, aligning with their religious or ethical beliefs. Members have more control over their healthcare expenses, empowering them to make informed decisions about their well-being.

Some healthcare sharing groups, such as those offered by Samaritan Ministries, center around a biblical approach to healthcare sharing. Medi-Share's plan focuses on sharing medical expenses among its members while praying for one another. OneShare Health presents different options within its healthcare sharing program. Each group comes with its own unique guidelines and membership requirements. When evaluating healthcare sharing programs, it's essential to consider their billing process, costs, and specific guidelines for members.

family at a doctors appointment

Analyzing Samaritan Ministries Healthcare Sharing

Samaritan Ministries operates as a healthcare-sharing ministry rooted in biblical principles of sharing in burdens. Members participate in a direct sharing process to share medical costs without the involvement of insurance. This approach relies on the collaborative effort of members to share each other’s medical expenses, fostering a sense of community and shared responsibility. Moreover, the ministry encourages members to offer personal support through prayer and mutual assistance with healthcare needs. Prospective members must adhere to specific guidelines and principles governing the sharing of medical costs within the Samaritan Ministries framework. Many find their guidelines more restrictive than others, requiring members to attend church three to four times every month.


Reviewing Medi-Share's Healthcare Sharing Program

Medi-Share's healthcare plan resonates with Christian ministry principles, emphasizing faith, sharing, and community support for medical costs. Members unite to share medical expenses and uphold each other through challenging times. Assessment of this program involves understanding requirements, costs, and sharing guidelines. The program outlines specific guidelines for sharing members' medical costs, promoting a sense of unity and support within the community. A comprehensive review delves into the details, ensuring that potential new members gain a deeper understanding of how the plan operates within the PPO network and the United States. Many consider Medi-Share to be one of the most costly Healthcare Sharing programs.


Evaluating OneShare Health's Offerings

When considering OneShare Health's offerings, it's essential to understand that they offer healthcare sharing plans tailored to meet members’ healthcare needs. Members share medical costs and support each other through sharing healthcare expenses and providing different options, costs, and guidelines. OneShare Health’s aim is to provide affordable healthcare sharing options. Those searching for healthcare options for the upcoming year should take a more detailed look into the specifics. This way, they can determine if OneShare Health's offerings perfectly fit their healthcare needs. Some have had concerns over their former name of, Aliera Healthcare, which was ordered to stop doing business in some states.

older couple comparing costs


Impact Health Sharing

Members are saving thousands when they switch to Impact. Sharing is simple, and options start as low as $73 for individuals and $378 for families. Impact designed four pricing options for individuals and families, as well as special pricing for seniors. Each month, members will pay a Monthly Share, and Impact will match those funds with another member’s eligible medical expenses. Impact will then send the payment to the provider directly. Once your family meets your annual Primary Responsibility Amount, other members will begin to share in your medical expenses. Members have comprehensive medical experience and access to preventative care, mental health care, prescription discounts, and telemedicine available 24/7. Impact offers no network restrictions when choosing a provider and is available year-round, even outside Open Enrollment periods. See what real healthcare sharing members are saying about their experience with Impact Health Sharing.


The Role of Insurance in Catastrophic Situations

A catastrophic health plan is a type of health plan that covers essential health benefits while requiring the highest level of cost-sharing. Catastrophic plans are designed to protect people in a worst-case scenario. Catastrophic plans have low monthly premiums and very high deductibles. In catastrophic situations, healthcare sharing plans serve as an alternative to health insurance, allowing members to share medical costs. New members looking for a perfect fit in healthcare can find a little bit of relief with this alternative to insurance. With a more detailed look into these healthcare sharing plans, it becomes evident that they are a viable option for managing medical costs during catastrophic situations.


Guideline Variations in Healthcare Sharing Plans

When exploring healthcare sharing plans, it's important to consider the variations in guideline requirements and the options offered. Members have the flexibility to choose from different levels of options within these plans, allowing them to select options that best suit their individual needs. Sharing ministries may have different cost-sharing arrangements, providing members a diverse range of choices. This variation allows the healthcare sharing organizations to offer many choices to a wide spectrum of individuals with requirements and preferences within the United States. Understanding these variations is crucial for new members, as it enables them to find the perfect fit for their healthcare needs without the constraints of a traditional insurance card. Some programs require members to pay for a portion of their medical bills before other members will share the costs.

cute couple with baby

Factors to Consider in Healthcare Sharing Plan Options

When choosing healthcare sharing plans, members should assess guidelines, cost-sharing options, and network restrictions. It's important to evaluate these plans based on specific healthcare needs, including sharing for medical expenses and other unique arrangements. Understanding the pre-existing condition limitations and cost-sharing structures is crucial, especially for those with chronic conditions that could become costly if not eligible to be shared. Members can benefit from flexibility in options within healthcare sharing plans, such as PPO networks and direct primary care. Considering factors like family members, medical bill sharing, and unlimited telehealth ensures the chosen plan aligns with individual requirements. Evaluating healthcare-sharing plans is essential for finding the perfect fit, making the annual unshared amount and the annual household portion a big deal for new and existing members.

Download this comparison guide to help you make a smart decision. 



Alternative Healthcare Options for Self-Employed Business Owners

Self-Employed Business Owners have the advantage to explore alternative healthcare options provided by some health share plans, making it a great alternative to traditional insurance. Impact Health Sharing offers flexibility in group options and cost-sharing arrangements suitable for self-employed individuals and entrepreneurs or 1099 contractors. A small handful of Sharing programs also present alternative healthcare solutions tailored to meet the needs of self-employed business owners, providing them with sharing variations to their employees. Whether it's a group of 2 or a group of 40, some health share plans can be the perfect fit for self-employed individuals seeking alternative healthcare options in the United States.

Who Can Benefit from a Healthcare Sharing Plan?

Individuals, small groups, seniors and families seeking affordable healthcare costs can find affordable choices in a healthcare sharing program. Health share programs provide an alternative to traditional health insurance, allowing individuals to share medical costs with like-minded members. This option is ideal for those looking for a healthcare sharing organization aligned with their values and interested in joining a community of members to share medical expenses. Direct sellers and other entrepreneurs face—once more—escalating health insurance premiums, deductibles, and out-of-pocket costs. This recent article stated, "They need health care for themselves and their families, but too often, they simply can’t afford the premiums – and they cannot afford to go without coverage."

Ideal Candidates for Healthcare Sharing Plans

Seeking cost-effective healthcare solutions and community-based support for medical expenses are primary considerations for ideal candidates for healthcare-sharing plans. Aligning with faith-based values and the desire for alternative healthcare options also make individuals suitable for these plans. The flexibility to choose healthcare options outside the traditional insurance network, especially for those with high deductibles or annual household portions, can make healthcare sharing a perfect fit. Moreover, healthy people searching for healthcare options and those interested in direct primary care and chiropractic care find healthcare sharing a viable alternative. Additionally, new members seeking a more detailed look into specific questions, including sharing for maternity under certain restrictions, enjoy what Healthcare Sharing has to offer.

healthy family cooking

Can Healthcare Sharing be a Viable Alternative for You?

Considering a cost-effective and community-based approach, healthcare sharing can be a viable alternative to traditional health insurance. Especially for those seeking faith-based options or affordable healthcare solutions, exploring healthcare sharing as an alternative is worth considering. Always look over the guidelines, as some groups have restrictions when it comes to tobacco use, routine physicals, and alternative medicine.


This member shared their review of Impact Health Sharing. "I’ve previously used two other sharing groups, and by far, Impact Health Sharing is the BEST! The application process was smooth and simple. The customer service was personal, responsive, and polite. I love that Impact Health Sharing functions just like what I was used to, and considering saving more than 60% monthly, I couldn’t be happier." - Ryan W.


In conclusion, healthcare sharing plans offer an alternative to traditional health insurance and have both advantages and disadvantages. It is crucial to understand the differences between healthcare sharing plans and traditional insurance before making a decision. In-depth reviews of popular healthcare sharing plans such as Impact Health Sharing, Christian Health Ministries, Samaritan Ministries, Medi-Share, and OneShare Health can provide valuable insights into their offerings and benefits. Additionally, it is important to consider factors such as religious variations and alternative healthcare options for self-employed business owners. While healthcare sharing plans may not be suitable for everyone, they can be an affordable alternative for individuals who meet certain criteria. Ultimately, understanding your healthcare needs and evaluating the pros and cons will help you make an informed decision about whether healthcare sharing is the right option for you.


See how much you could save by switching to Impact.